The title of this episode alone has me bracing for the worst, especially considering very few of the characters in this show can even say the words Valar or Valinor as Tolkien intended. For the record, the vowel a in Elvish words should always sound like the a in father. So the val part of both words should be like the vol in volume. (I’ve only heard Celeborn say it correctly, actually, to his credit.)
In everyday speech, of course we can pronounce it however we want. Let’s not be jerks about it! Even as Tolkien fans, just say what’s comfortable. But the in-world characters really ought to get it right, particularly the Elves using their own language.
First, a reminder of all my previous reviews of past episodes (and other bits and bobs): Concerning The Rings of Power.
Starting with Galadriel in the woods again.
- One warg and a handful of Orcs have Galadriel on the run, even though she took down a snow-troll like it was no big deal in season 1.

- Nazg-Theo gets the drop on her, despite being a mortal kid and her being a thousands-of-years-old Noldo with a way more powerful Ring than the one he’s got.
- Well, there’s no talk of Noldor in this show, so she’s just a generic High Elf. Remember, they’ve never even alluded to her having royal blood or being elder to Gil-galad himself, more’s the shame.
- I’m very glad and hopeful that Theo is remorseful. I hope the writers see this through and that it’s not a fake-out. I really want to see one mortal reject Ringwraithhood, and why not a character we actually know? If it is real, does Sauron not know that one of his Nazgnagôl is trying to go rogue?
- What I don’t like is all the Gollum-esque creeping over the ring Theo craves. Constantly jonesing for it like it’s a drug, as if every Ring of Power works just like a mini version of the One Ring will be.

Over to Númenor.
- The interplay between Elendil, his son Anárion, and Kemen, all good. The context of what’s going on is interesting but ultimately a waste of time. So much time compression in the show, only to fluff it out with an army-to-army civil war that Tolkien never wrote. But I like the characters and I like spending time with them.
- My guess is, this impending battle of King’s Men vs. Faithful won’t actually happen. Battle will be halted. But still, the plot is using up precious time.
Now over to the dungeons of Barad-dûr, where Sauron has already installed Celeborn.

- I’m guessing Celeborn didn’t get to sit sidesaddle on the fell beast for the journey here? Was he carried in the beast’s claws?
- This back and forth “No, she likes me more” between the Dark Lord and the future Lord of the Galadhrim is already so tiresome and petty. Schoolyard posturing.
- Sauron gets so mad he punches Celeborn. They might as well have had him punch a hole in the wall like a raging dad or some jealous boyfriend.
- Sauron bids the Orcs bring in the machine. Oh, good.

Back to Khazad-dûm.
- I hate how we got here—how the kingship passed from Durin to Thráin—but I still enjoy the banter, the arguments, and the generally spirit of the dramas going on here.
- Durin in a cage.
- Disa in house arrest.
- The wee’ns threatened! Thráin’s a jerk. I especially like it when the brothers talk about their childhood shenanigans and their dad. Good stuff.
- Love the stone-singing and Disa’s in particular. But I’m not wild about it taking place wherever, as from an opera balcony. I’d rather see her singing while marching through tunnels. But I get why.

Galadriel and Nazg-Theo.
- Galadriel presumably used her Elf Ring to summon a saddled horse. Sweet, more Ring-powers we didn’t know about.
- Galadriel brings them to the now-famous overlook near future Lothlórien.
- Never mind that forest would actually be Lindórinand at this point in time, and actually have a population of Nandor Elves already at this time. Here it’s just a scouted location for future homesteading.
- If Galadriel is now holding one of the Nine Rings, I wonder why just throwing it a river or a deep crack somewhere isn’t even on the table. Why carry it into Mordor? Theo wants to destroy it. I would think just getting away from it would be enough from his POV. Again, it’s almost like they’ve both read The Lord of the Rings and know that destroying rings is a thing they’re supposed to consider.

Speaking of Mordor . . .
- The pressing of heavy weight upon Celeborn continues.
- Sauron’s wordiness has gotten boring. He’s strayed into monologueing-like-Voldemort territory now.
- Trees and stars, hah! You go, Celeborn.

Númenor again.
- Again, I enjoy the conversations, particularly when they involve Elrond and Míriel, but so much of this feels like filler to me.
- Travel times back and forth between the Faithful havens on the west coast and the capital city goes from weeks to nothing at all.
- Míriel sees again! Benefit of that famous time when one of the Elf Rings was brough to Númenor by the High King Gil-galad himself.
- Ahh, so Pharazôn is going to pop the question, is he? I guess I’m glad they’re bringing this part of the story closer to the text. It didn’t need to take so long.

Cut to the cells of Mordor Penitentiary.
- I knew something sneaky was going on, but I admit, I thought the show hand-waved Galadriel’s infiltration of Barad-dûr and that the trap was Celeborn himself. I thought Celeborn was Sauron in disguise.
- But they flipped that. It’s clever.
- But Celeborn is a dummy and not only falls for it, he starts spouting the “secret” that she already knows? Come on.

- The kiss was just par for the course. Sauron does this after he’s got what he wanted.
- That Celeborn just stares in calm horror is hard to believe. It’s not just not his wife, it’s that guy, and there’s no way he’s got minty-fresh breath. Not a chance. (For that matter, no way does Celeborn.)
- So now we’ve arrived at two requirements for the making of the One Ring:
- (1) Silver and/or gold from Valinor is needed. I never liked this, even with the Valinorean dagger, because there’s no way with all the Elves in Middle-earth that there haven’t been plenty of other precious metals from Valinor among them. It can’t just be that one dagger and that one forge hammer.
- Side note: That is a cool hammer. Even that it was Fëanor’s forge hammer is cool, though I don’t like the idea that he needed a hammer to “forge” some gems. What the Silmarils are made and how they were made should always remain a complete mystery.
- (2) Heat enough to melt them properly. Mount Doom was right under his nose, of course. Silly to have not thought of that. But of course he’s either going to need some Balrog heat or just a Balrog’s consultation on the matter. We’ll see.
- (1) Silver and/or gold from Valinor is needed. I never liked this, even with the Valinorean dagger, because there’s no way with all the Elves in Middle-earth that there haven’t been plenty of other precious metals from Valinor among them. It can’t just be that one dagger and that one forge hammer.
The watercooler kiss (every season needs one, right?) aside, I like seeing Sauron use his shapechanging abilities. He should be doing this more often! To Orcs, even! To his servants. Hell, even up in Gundabad, if he’d pretended to be someone else the moment Galadriel spots him, he might have gotten some information from her. Who knows?

One response to “RoP : S3 Ep 6: From Valinor”
[…] Episode 6: From Valinor […]
LikeLike